The IRS is Watching: Understanding Form 9984, the Auditor’s Secret Weapon

An audit by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) can be an intimidating experience for any taxpayer. The process often feels opaque, with a flurry of document requests, interviews, and correspondence. However, behind the scenes, every action taken by an IRS examiner is meticulously documented on a crucial internal form: Form 9984, Examining Officer’s Activity Record. While taxpayers may never see this form during an audit, it plays a pivotal role in the examination process and can be a powerful tool. 

What is Form 9984? 

Form 9984 is an internal IRS document that serves as the official activity log for an examination case. It is a chronological record of all actions taken by the examiner, group manager, clerical staff, taxpayer, and the taxpayer’s representative throughout the audit process.  It is a brief summary of actions taken that provides a complete and concise case history. 

Think of Form 9984 as the official diary of your audit. Every phone call, every piece of correspondence, every meeting, and every research activity is supposed to be documented on this form. This creates a detailed audit trail that can be reviewed by IRS managers and, importantly, can be accessed by the taxpayer. 

The Role of Form 9984 in Interest Abatement Claims 

One of the most significant applications of Form 9984 for taxpayers is in claims for interest abatement under Internal Revenue Code § 6404(e). This section of the tax code gives the IRS the discretion to abate (reduce or eliminate) interest on an underpayment of tax if the interest is attributable to an “unreasonable error or delay” by an IRS employee in performing a “ministerial or managerial act.” 

To successfully claim interest abatement, a taxpayer must demonstrate that the IRS caused an unreasonable delay and that the taxpayer did not significantly contribute to that delay. This is where Form 9984 becomes invaluable. The detailed activity log on the form can provide the evidence needed to support or refute a claim for interest abatement. 

For example, if an examiner misplaces a case file for an extended period, this would be considered a “managerial act” that could lead to an unreasonable delay. The entry on Form 9984 documenting the loss of the file and the subsequent delay in the examination would be critical evidence in an interest abatement claim. 

Why is this important? There is a widespread belief that interest cannot be abated. Many think that only penalties abatement is possible. Form 9984 opens up the possibility for interest abatement in the right circumstance. 

Ministerial vs. Managerial Acts 

Treasury Regulation § 301.6404-2 provides definitions and examples of ministerial and managerial acts: 

•Ministerial Act: A procedural or mechanical act that does not involve judgment or discretion. For example, transferring a case to another office after a transfer has been approved. 

•Managerial Act: An administrative act involving the temporary or permanent loss of records or the exercise of judgment related to personnel management. For example, a supervisor’s decision to send an agent to training without reassigning their cases. 

It is important to note that a decision regarding the proper application of tax law is neither a ministerial nor a managerial act. Therefore, delays caused by the complexity of a legal issue are generally not grounds for interest abatement. 

The Legal Framework for IRS Examinations 

The authority for the IRS to conduct examinations and the procedures they must follow are grounded in the Internal Revenue Code and related regulations. 

•IRC § 7602, Examination of Books and Witnesses: This is the foundational statute that grants the IRS broad authority to examine books and records, summon individuals for testimony, and take other actions to ascertain the correctness of any return. 

•IRC § 7605, Time and Place of Examination: This section provides important taxpayer protections, including the requirement that the time and place of an examination be reasonable and that taxpayers not be subjected to unnecessary examinations or more than one inspection of their books for each tax year. 

•Revenue Procedure 2005-32: This revenue procedure provides detailed guidance on when a case is considered closed and the strict procedures the IRS must follow to reopen a closed case. 

Form 9984 is the primary tool used by the IRS to document its compliance with these statutory and procedural requirements. 

Conclusion 

IRS Form 9984 is more than just an internal administrative form; it is the backbone of the examination record. It provides a detailed account of every action taken during an audit and serves as a critical piece of evidence in a variety of situations, from interest abatement claims to appeals and litigation. 

Taxpayers and their representatives who understand the significance of Form 9984 can gain a significant advantage in navigating the complexities of an IRS audit. By leveraging the information contained in this “secret” document, you can ensure that your rights are protected and that you have the best possible chance of achieving a favorable outcome. 

To learn more about how to fix your IRS issues, click the link to watch the free video, The Ultimate Guide to Solving Your IRS Tax Problems: 

Watch Video